Truth and Discernment
September 1st, 2008We routinely disqualify testimony that would plead for extenuation. That is, we are so persuaded of the rightness of our judgment as to invalidate evidence that does not confirm us in it. Nothing that deserves to be called truth could ever be arrived at by such means. Marilynne Robinson, The Death of Adam
Matt Brown and I were chatting Monday night. Here’s a blurb.
Matthew: A Catholic can commit a murder and go to confession and receive absolution, but the priest will give penance. What is penance, but the ‘turning away’. So a good priest would say: ‘ your penance is to take the earthly consequences of your sin’
Matthew: The Wolf (murderer, abuser) probably was a victim at some point and has a story and needs grace, but even though there is love there are consequences.
me: ? Yeah?
Matthew: Yeah what? People mistake grace for letting someone off the hook.
People mistake love for leniency
Matthew: Jesus and the tax collector who pays people back more than he stole shows that God is interested in justice. Heck, the crucifiction shows that.
BUT God is also interested in love, grace, compassion, and truth
So that quote struck me
Struck me in light of a lot of the conversations we had yesterday
The conversation Matt mentions above was about castrating sex offenders. Apparently, there is a move (I’ve forgotten where) to make castration an option after the first offense and mandatory after the second. Certainly, we want to make sure that sex offenders never get the chance to repeat their crimes. But, is castration the answer? The Hemphills and the Browns had a lively after-dinner discussion.
The way this quote strikes me is that, to me, it confirms the need to be in community. We all see life through a lens. Last year, Ed used the metaphor of the slats of a fence. I thought that was brilliant. People who are genuinely seeking Truth will arrive at some type of truth. But, like looking at a yard through the slats of a fence, each person will see Truth a little differently. Their understanding of Truth will be colored by their experiences, their histories, their belief systems. Their truth may be correct, but, by definition, it will be too small to be Truth.
God is love. Yes, He says that about Himself in His Word. (That means it’s in the Bible.)
It is not God’s will that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance. (That’s in the Bible, too.)
So, God doesn’t want anyone to perish. That’s certainly one slat. But, what do you do, then, with verses like, “But the cowardly, the unbelieving, the vile, the murderers, the sexually immoral, those who practice magic arts, the idolaters and all liars—their place will be in the fiery lake of burning sulfur. This is the second death.” (That’s in the Bible, too. Revelation 21:8)
To help get your head around some truths that are too big for one person, you need other people. You need other perspectives, other points of view. Sometimes you need your friends to challenge you when you are “disqualifying testimony”.
Evergreen is really, really good at loving people. But, do we do an adequate job of challenging each other? Have you been challenged? Is your truth larger now than it was a year or two ago? Has your picture of God changed? How? Does the quote strike you differently? How?

Exploding the Box
